I know what you are thinking: what a joke! Seriously though, I purchased this game for the PS2 and was thouroughly surprised. Most people bombed this game dubbing it the lowest ratings of all the guitar hero games, however this is simply not true. The main problem here is how does one review a rhythm game? Now I know I stated why I was not going to review rhythm games, but I feel as though this game should be an exception simply because it is a well known series and people will understand the ups and downs of it better. So, why do I stand by this game? Could it be that I paid $50 for it hoping that I would not be disappointed? Am I just a Guitar Hero junkie? These answers coming up next…
Lets begin with the facts. This game is another cop-out title produced by Neversoft only because they figured that enough people would purchase it because it dons the “Guitar Hero” title. As you may have guessed, the game is heavily Aerosmith themed and is automatically shittier than other guitar hero games simply because no one cares about Aerosmith. Regardless, there are 30 main songs, and a slew of extra songs included in the game totally a little over 40 songs. Not too much bang for your buck, but I will say this: the game is better than Guitar Hero III. Big words, but I wholeheartedly feel it is true mainly due to one fact; Guitar Hero Aerosmith actually makes you feel like you are an important part in the song. This feeling of “being a part of somthing big” is something that was completely lost in Guitar Hero III. Ask most anyone and they will say that they prefer Guitar Hero II or other titles even thought they are easier and its just because the third game lost that vibe with the sloppy execution on almost every aspect. Aerosmith gives more power to the player by giving rather interesting, unique, and involving solos in practically every song. Included in the set list are also some songs that inspired Aerosmith on their voyage to rock fame, and each track is a fun little side note but the songs really just go to show how much better the Aerosmith songs are. The difficulty of the songs are a little out of whack and some songs occur earlier than others even thought they are harder (Sweet Emotion and Dream On should be switched for example) but overall the songs are much easier than those found in GH III. For me, this was good considering the difficulty of GH III took away from the fun of the game because songs were difficult for the wrong reasons. What becomes of this is a lame online community that constantly play the hardest songs because they have mastered the most difficult parts to a point where there is no competition and you might as well play a computer. For Aerosmith the songs have less to do about the general difficulty, but more to do about the length. What is interesting for this game is that the songs are rather lengthy, which is both good and bad. You certainly get your moneys worth while playing this game, however most of the time you just want a song to end. I looked at the length of the songs positively because even if a song is easy, I know that the longer it is the harder it is to full combo. Just the fact that these songs would piss off the perfectionists of the Guitar Hero franchise put a smile on my face.
The graphics in the game leave much room for improvement but then again, who cares? The graphics certainly did not get worse than GH III so I don’t think points should be docked for that. Although the graphics are still shit, the motion capture work for this game is actually damn good. Stephen Tyler’s mouth moves smoothly to the tunes as every song as been motion captured to his mouth (crazy, but it is convincing). The drummer does not look like a robot anymore and everyone else is animated in interesting and sometimes unique ways…overall impressive for a cash cow title. The bonus features for the game are generally stock, however there are some real nice gems. Playing as Run from RunDMC is a fun bonus, and the video interviews with Aerosmith are extremely entertaining and informative. There are plenty of characters and even more guitars than GH III to chose from summing to a large product. How good is this game really though? Well it is just par; a silly excuse for an in between game from GH III to IV. The flaws of GH III are all here but it’s gained a little from the prior game so in a way it is better but it does not even come close to the classic games in the franchise. Just about every song is an Aerosmith song and this is just annoying since songs start to sound alike and they all have that Joe Perry vibe. Not to say that the guitar parts are the same (because they are well varied) but it would be nice to have different bands and types of rock to play.
This review is short, just like this game. GHA could have been good (like GH Rock the 80’s surprisingly), but instead it is just mediocre and mediocrity is not worth $50.
Major Infractions (-10)
Song list is short and not worth $50
Songs go on for WAY too long
Too much Aerosmith
Infractions (-5)
Timing varies from song to song
No real difficulty
Minor Infractions (-1)
Load times seem longer
Final Score: 59 (Out of 100)